Selected Currency
Members
Islamorada, Florida, United States

Amara Cay Resort

Boutique Beach Hotel

Trip Advisor Rating '.$item_trip.' Our Rating 8.4
 

Amara Cay Resort, a beachfront retreat in Islamorada, Florida, captures the laid-back charm of the Upper Keys, blending sport fishing heritage with a tranquil vibe, just minutes from the History of Diving Museum.

The 110 rooms feature air-conditioned spaces, flat-screen TVs, work desks, safety deposit boxes, minibars, and private bathrooms with premium toiletries. Some rooms include balconies with ocean or garden views, creating a restful sanctuary for couples or travellers. An oceanfront pool ensures seamless relaxation.

ReelCatch restaurant serves breakfasts with fresh fruits and local seafood dishes, while the Tiki Bar crafts custom cocktails, accompanied by soft island melodies, fostering a warm, inviting atmosphere.

An on-site fitness centre supports active routines, while bicycle rentals and nearby water sports like snorkeling and fishing explore Islamorada's vibrant waters. A concierge arranges tours to Anne's Beach or Windley Key Fossil Reef, weaving in the Keys' lively pulse.

Situated a short drive from Anne's Beach, Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park, and the History of Diving Museum, with Key West International Airport accessible, Amara Cay Resort offers paid parking and easy access to Islamorada's coastal landmarks. This retreat blends modern comfort with the lively rhythm of the Florida Keys' heart.

Available Board

Room Only

Rooms & Suites

General Facilities

Activities

  • Bicycle Rental
  • Beach
  • Water Sport Facilities On Site
  • Snorkelling
  • Diving
  • Cycling
  • Fishing
  • Golf Course (within 3 Km)

Wellness

  • Outdoor Swimming Pool
  • Fitness
  • Sun Umbrellas
  • Sun Loungers Or Beach Chairs
  • Fitness Centre

General

  • Luggage Storage
  • Express Check-in/Check-out
  • 24-hour Front Desk
  • Daily Housekeeping
  • Laundry
  • Fax/Photocopying
  • Meeting/Banquet Facilities

Hotel Reviews

Location rating Location
Sleep Quality rating Sleep Quality
Rooms rating Rooms
Service rating Service
Value rating Value
Cleanliness rating Cleanliness
5 rating
March 2026

All the help was great! Damian in the bar made the stay even better

5 rating
February 2026

We had an amazing 4 days/nights at Amara Cay resort. Loved the decor and variety of seating options in the lobby and dining areas. Be sure and take a selfie by the "keys." Our room (125) and lanai...

2 rating
February 2026

Disappointed. Very expensive for poor quality. Room had stains on the bed frame, hair and stains on the couch, sand on the floor, rusting in the bathroom, and stains on some of the towels. We asked...

3 rating
February 2026

Okay if you are bringing your family with kids. Not so much as a couple. Beach feels artificial.

Read All Reviews

Average Weather

Ave Daily Temp °C
Ave Monthly Rain mm

Jan
23
63
Feb
26
51
Mar
28
28
Apr
30
105
May
32
84
Jun
33
248
Jul
33
283
Aug
33
256
Sep
33
328
Oct
31
36
Nov
27
46
Dec
25
32

Hotel Location

Rates Nightly From

CA$123 Per Person

Search & Book